One of the longest-lasting group chats I’m in has only three people in it: one friend from my undergrad, one friend from my Master’s, and me. Even though I got to know them independently, the two friends actually went to the same high school together, and then, eventually, we all ended up in Munich.
I try to stay as true to myself as I can while writing online, and, on the whole, I think I’m doing a good job. But if you know me only through my work, writing, or even the occasional email exchange, you might be shocked at the kind of messages going through our group chat.
Essentially, we all revert to our 14-year-old selves in there. It’s full of thinly veiled insults, bad jokes, and constant trolling of what’s happening in the news, which one of the guys consistently supplies thanks to his well-tuned RSS feed. There’s dark humor, inappropriate comments, and many unfiltered opinions. The chat loosely mirrors how we behave in real life when we’re together, and while it’s only a sliver of a reflection of who each of us is as a person, it feels like a safe space in which we protect something the public is slowly losing: the healing power of politically incorrect humor.
Today, many outspoken voices are quick to decry any statement or event one could deem racist, sexist, opportunist, or any flavor of many kinds of isms. I’m sure you hear the phrase all the time in private conversations: “You can’t say that in public anymore.” Whether the people do it through shaming or the government does it through violence and technology, the problem with censorship is that it never solves what it censors. You can’t make reality go away by not talking about it.
A joke, meanwhile, no matter how inappropriate—and, in some ways, especially the inappropriate—not only disarms what could end up as an argument that ruins a friendship. It also draws reality into the light. Humor can acknowledge a problem without feigning an easy solution exists. It can make an issue what we call “salonfähig” in German, “parlor-presentable,” without taking a holier-than-thou attitude. There’s no need for anyone, or, sometimes, everyone, in the conversation to pretend they’re going to try and save the world from our self-made human maladies. You just laugh, remember the issue exists, and move on. That collective awareness is worth more than a million rants on social media.
My friends are Swabian. The stereotype is that Swabians like to save money and will go to extreme lengths to do so. My friends certainly fit that bill. It’s easy to make a joke like, “You’re so cheap, I’m surprised you’re buying your toilet paper instead of stealing it at work!” This will usually get a good laugh out of the group, followed by one of several amazing events: For one, either friend might admit they’re actually sometimes too stingy. For another, they may take pride in their habit of saving, even if they sometimes overdo it. And, finally, everyone has a chance to remember that, oh, yeah, workplace theft exists in our country, and it’s actually a real problem neither of us is looking to make worse. Probably better to keep hunting for deals on toilet paper!
Best of all? Sometimes, we do all three of these. Every now and then, we might even continue a real conversation about workplace theft, get informed on the topic, and consider what one might do about it. Chances are, nothing else will happen—but that’s no different from most conversations where some smarty-pants ends the discussion entirely with one knockout argument.
Don’t let the media, social or otherwise, fool you. In real life, real people still have a real sense of humor. Nobody’s perfect, and everyone can take one for the team’s laughter on occasion. Be generous. Be forgiving. And remember that humor can heal more situations than silence will ever successfully break.