Someone once asked me: “I met this girl who ticks off every box on my list—except she’s slept with 16 guys and cheated. Do I just look past it?”
Knowing nothing else about the pair of them, I tried to gather the facts. Here’s my response:
- She likes to change what ‘husband-material’ her sweater’s made of with a frequency that’s somewhere between fresh underwear and an oil change.
If she’s 20 and started dating at 15, that’s the equivalent of a new guy every 4 months. I don’t know how old she is. You do the math. - She’s willing to break whatever ethical code she previously agreed upon with her partner to make sure that man-flow is kept up at all times.
- You, on the other hand, need a girl to comply with some arbitrary checklist to even consider dating her.
Of course we know too little to give good advice, but so far, it doesn’t exactly sound like a match made in heaven.
She’s the Road Runner, you’re the Coyote. By the time you’ve made up your mind, she’ll have moved on. I think this time, it’s your turn to run.

PS: Don’t bother packing the checklist.